Gary Neville: Erik ten Hag deserves one more year at Manchester United | Football News

Gary Neville says Erik Ten Hag deserves an extra year as Manchester United manager, but Jamie Carragher says they are ‘going backwards’ – who’s right?

The Dutchman’s future is under scrutiny ahead of Manchester United’s match with Arsenal at Old Trafford on Sunday, live on Sky Sports.

United are eighth in the Premier League and will fail to qualify for Europe through the league – although a win in the FA Cup final against Manchester City will remedy that.

Many, including Sky Sports Carragher, has campaigned for Ten Hag to replace him at the end of the season although former United legend Neville feels the manager should have an extra year to prove himself to the new ownership.

Who do you agree with?

The Case: Nev supports Ten Hag for another year

Neville said Sky Sports: “I don’t see a suitable replacement for Ten Hag available. Bayern Munich are struggling to find a replacement, and others are struggling. I think we need to stick with Ten Hag and give him another season – an injury-free season – to see if United can return to last season’s standards.” He won the title and finished the season in the top four.

“Players and managers have struggled to adapt to Old Trafford in the last 10 years. These players and managers were fantastic when United signed them, so there is something fundamentally wrong that is causing this difficulty. Perhaps new ownership and staff will allow that.” These players and the manager to feel more stable.

He added: “As the sun rises, Manchester United will start winning again.

“I don’t know when it will happen. It can’t be a guarantee, but I know these things go in cycles.”

“I lived my whole childhood watching Liverpool, Everton and Arsenal win titles, win the old league, and I was patient.

Please use Chrome browser for an easily accessible video player

Speaking about his interview with Manchester United boss Erik Ten Hag, Gary Neville suggested that giving the Dutchman at least one more season at Old Trafford is in the best interests of everyone at the club.

“I had to wait until I was 18 or 19 when Manchester United won the league title for the first time in my life – and then we won a load of league titles, and now we haven’t won one for 10 years.

“I know very well that in my lifetime – I hope – Manchester United will win trophies, but they will win trophies again. We will do it right, just as Liverpool will do, just as Arsenal will do.”

“You can’t keep these great clubs down. I’m sorry, they’re too big, they’re too established, they have a great history, they have slumps.

“Look, hopefully in three or four weeks’ time the FA Cup final against Manchester City, which is a very tough game, we know how good City are, but if they can defy the odds who knows where that might lead.

Sunday, May 12 at 3:30 p.m

“As you know, in the 1989-90 season Sir Alex Ferguson won the FA Cup which put faith in him in a group of players.

He added: “Then they won the European Cup Winners’ Cup, then they won the League Cup, and then finally they won the league title.

“It’s been building brick by brick, step by step, and it may be around the corner, or it may be a few years away, but they will win again, Manchester United. It’s inevitable.”

Please use Chrome browser for an easily accessible video player

Free viewing: Highlights of Crystal Palace’s victory over Manchester United in the English Premier League.

The case against – “£380 million spent and nothing changes”

Writing in his country cableCarragher said: “Eric ten Hag might analyze the first two years of his next opponent at the Emirates and see hope. He could certainly use it as evidence to Sir Jim Ratcliffe that his sacking demands are premature.

“It will shock many that in the same number of Premier League games, the Dutchman’s record is only slightly better than Arteta’s.

“Ten Hag won five more goals from his first 73 Premier League games. They lost two fewer. United scored five more goals but, remarkably, conceded another 16 goals. As Arteta won the FA Cup and Community Shield, Ten Hag lifted the cup”. League Cup and may add the FA Cup.

“Arteta’s performance levels at Arsenal have never declined as consistently as those of Manchester United under Ten Hag.

“Although the league standard was breaking false records, the cups and Europe were redemption. In all competitions, Arteta won more of his first 100 games than Arsene Wenger.

Please use Chrome browser for an easily accessible video player

Jamie Carragher explains Kai Havertz’s influence on Arsenal and how he has helped them be stronger defensively.

“This meant that amid the setbacks there was always a sense of final destination. When Arsenal enjoyed good results and performances, you could see the fruits of the labor on the training ground. Arsenal took steps back to move forward.

“Manchester United, by contrast, took a step forward last year, but have taken several steps back since then.

“Ten Hag took over United with a huge reputation due to his work at Ajax, especially when he led them to the Champions League semi-finals. He was not presented as a young coach but at the age of 52 he was supposed to be ready.” The one who will impose a clear vision United had qualified for the Champions League in two of the three seasons before Ten Hag’s appointment, and there was a belief that talented players needed outstanding coaching and a change in culture on the training ground.

“Like Arteta, Ten Hag had no choice but to use available personnel to be more realistic in his first season. During his first three transfer windows, United spent just over £380m and nothing changed as they bought more deadwood than they did. “. Of Ten Hag’s first-choice Premier League squad (defeat to Brighton in August 2022), seven are likely to remain first-choice, only two have left the club, and another, Jadon Sancho, is about to play the Champions League final on loan in Borussia Dortmund.

“United have been regularly outclassed by rivals, losing 6-3 to Manchester City and 7-0 to Liverpool, while also struggling against mid-table teams in the Premier League.

“Even when United have had good results under Ten Hag, I have a real hard time recalling any exceptionally good performance with a conscious, proactive system of play. Two years on, they are not set up like a top team.

“None of Arteta’s disappointing losses were remotely comparable to the 4-0 defeat at Crystal Palace on Monday night. Worryingly for Ten Hag, the biggest difference is that it is not the appointment of the owner. Arsenal’s board has staked its reputation on Arteta becoming good Logic suggests that Ratcliffe would be more likely to stand or fall based on his managerial choice.

Watch Manchester United vs Arsenal live on Sky Sports Premier League from 3.30pm on Sunday; Kick-off at 4.30pm

Ad Content | Stream Sky Sports on now

TV promo now for April 2024

Stream Sky Sports live without a contract on a month or day NOW membership. Instant access to live events from the Premier League, EFL, F1, England Cricket and much more.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Back to top button

Adblock Detected